Mortgage burden crimps retirement plans: study
Tired of rising property taxes and empty rooms, 86 per cent of boomers are planning on moving to a smaller home when they retire.
However, even though they agree it’s important to pay off the mortgage long before then, only 43 per cent have actually done so, according to recent research from TD Canada Trust.
In fact, 54 per cent admit to having paid off less than half of the debt on their house, meaning they have a ways to go before thinking about retirement.
Truth is, pre-retirees today are carrying unprecedented levels of debt, which could become a big problem for them when they’re ready to stop working – which is why many financial planners caution homeowners against carrying mortgage debt into retirement.
Even though interest rates are still near record lows, paying down that mortgage debt (the median balance for Canadian retirees is actually around $82,000) is likely the best investment you can make as retirement becomes a reality, the CRR reports.
"It is unlikely that many retired households will be able to earn a return on risk-free investments, such as bank certificates of deposit, Treasury bills, and Treasury bonds, that will exceed the cost of their mortgage," says analyst Anthony Webb.
And don’t be lured by any talk about mortgages being “good debt” – chances are they’re from U.S. sources.
Our neighbours to the south have been enjoying a substantial tax break on their mortgage interest for some time now. And while such a policy in Canada would be extremely popular, it’s unlikely to happen any time soon.
Do you see yourself carrying a mortgage into retirement? Or is that what’s keeping you working in the first place?
By Gordon Powers, MSN Money
Posted by: Guy | Nov 4, 2021 9:28:38 AM
Are you kidding me? I'm 46 years old and I am agree at myself for still having 6 more years left on my mortage. It should have been paid off by 45 which was my initial goal from my Financial Plan. However, losing a job for 8 months and then having to care for an elderly parent for 5 months (leave of absence) simply postponed things. I would say that both these circumstances were not expected but I also understand that life does throw you a curve ball sometimes. Having said that, my house will still be paid way before I retire. I live a very good life, decent paying job and have 3 kids. So it's hard for me to understand how so many retire with debt unless they were simply living above their means or some dire unfortunate curve balls? We can't all blame too much taxes. This is something we can surely control, no?
Posted by: joanna marcinkowski | Nov 4, 2021 3:42:10 PM
We have been mortgage free for two years. Ages 55/50 Wetravel 4/5 times year and put two sons through university (one more to go) also I have worked only parttime since being married. We never overspend and always pay credit cards 100% (We have earned many free trips(plane) for our strict credit card use and paying. It can be done its called smart spending.
Posted by: don | Nov 5, 2021 12:22:37 PM
i too will have my mortagae paid off before I retire. A lot of problems do have to do with spending habits and lifestyle choices. My spouse and I have been together a long time and neither of us has made the large dollar but together, manged correctly, we have done alright. I speaking with people in my age group a lot would have been mortgage free but their marriages ended in divorce and they have had to start over after years of building. I do attribute the divorce rate to some of this.
Posted by: Terri | Nov 5, 2021 2:33:05 PM
Ok This may seem a little selfish but.... I wouldn't donate that much of the money to charity. I would by myself a house as I don't have one of my own and everything for it, a car, repair both my parents houses, give some to my brother, set up a collage fund for my nephew, take my whole family on a trip. I would how ever if I won a big amount since I wouldn't need to work, I would donate a lot of my time to charity/orginizatons(ex: cancer center at the hospital in Regina and maybe some women shelters and places for the disabled)
Posted by: Canuckguy | Nov 5, 2021 9:32:09 PM
@ Don.
You hit it on the nose with the comment " a lot would have been mortgage free but their marriages ended in divorce". I however disagree with your comment: "I do attribute the divorce rate to some of this."
I think it plays a big role, not just 'some' role.
It happened to me, had a house paid for by 1986. Lost it in divorce. Had my current house paid by 1995. Retired 10 years later. To do that, I did not to the yearly big trips to warmer climes or to Europe like my aquaintances. They are my age and still paying mortages and some did not even divorce.
Posted by: Jim | Nov 6, 2021 11:23:21 AM
You have a none crystabal future when a divorse at 57 with a plant clorsure bankrupsy,had house payed off,then 85% morgage and housing market crumbles in area because of factory clousures
had to move to another area for work. Talking to my fellow workers I'm not the only one some of you are lucky with good companies and care about their workforse When they go broke you are lucky to get a red cent.
Posted by: Al | Nov 8, 2021 7:35:06 AM
I can't believe these numbers, they are atrocious. I have my house paid off (age 38) and I don't even live in Canada. I've had decent renters in it for a decade and sent top up money but really I could have finished it earlier than when i did if i didn't have another house overseas.
I wouldn't make more than $50,000/year Canadian. if that's what you are thinking. I'm not rich by any means but i have no debts perhaps that's why I'm light years ahead of people.
Posted by: Al | Nov 8, 2021 7:42:58 AM
Oh..i forgot to mention that people with mortgages at these ages should be ashamed of themselves. Do you know the saying 'save for a rainy day'? Well, it happens! Canadans really spread themselves too thinly and stuff happens, plan on it.
That's why you should have an emergency fund of 6months salary mimimum. Most people don't have 6weeks, don't be one of them. Excuses are like ....... everyone has one. Tales of woe, everyones' got those as well but at the end of the day....you should have planned on it better.
I simply can not fathom how a person, even a single income family could not be out of debt by the time they are 50 let alone 55,60 or 65.....perhaps you people were raised poorly by your parents.
Posted by: Lisa | Nov 8, 2021 8:10:23 AM
Yes "don," starting over and debt seem to go hand in hand in most cases. There is a reason I try to tell everyone, don't divorce unless you absolutely must. Think it through very, very hard. It just could be much better to just stay. And no...I don't see myself carrying a mortgage into retirement. I can't ever see myself being that financially foolish.
Posted by: Judi | Nov 8, 2021 12:13:36 PM
How about some gratitude people! We all have stories to tell, let's tell a new story a good story.
Posted by: Susan | Nov 9, 2021 8:17:00 AM
I am 47 year old single mother, got divorced at 42. Bought a house and ended up sleeping on the floor so I didnt have to borrow money to buy a bed. Now 5 years later I have a comfortable bed and I have 2 more years to go to have my semi detached home paid for. As a society I feel we use credit far to easily. Buy now pay later. I have very little sympathy for those who cry its so hard. If you are able bodied go out and get 2 jobs or 3 jobs whatever it takes. We try to keep up with the Jones' and funny thing is the Jones' are doing the same thing with the Smiths'. Once you are in the habit of saving instead of spending things seem to come easier. Its not divorce that is preventing individuals from being mortgage free, its the money management habits of these individuals.
Posted by: Roger Williams | Nov 9, 2021 9:35:21 AM
I was not planning to have a mortgage when I retired, but my job was outsourced just as I turned 65. However, we live quite comfortably in our Mini-home. 3 bedrooms, 1 1/2 baths. Total cost of the mortgage, power bill, taxes, insurance, and maintenance is $690.00 a month. We did manage to pay off all our credit card debt a year ago. Just have one CC now for hotel reservations, etc., but that gets paid off every month. It is a huge relief, paying cash for purchases. I would recommend that you go through the hardship of cutting up the credit cards and paying cash. It saves us $300 a month in interest on those cursed cards..
Posted by: snow | Nov 10, 2021 9:00:19 AM
It’s a pretty interesting tool. I will definitely be using it once I get the chance. Thanks for sharing!
Posted by: snow | Nov 10, 2021 9:01:23 AM
It’s a pretty interesting tool. I will definitely be using it once I get the chance. Thanks for sharing!
Posted by: Elizabeth | Nov 10, 2021 4:45:22 PM
I am a 57 year old been married for years retired 10 years ago because of health problems my husband retired 15 years ago for the same reason. I am so happy we can still live in our home YES we still have a mortage. If prices keep going up which is the big PROBLEM we may not able to stay in our home for much longer. Even if you don't have a mortage with the old age pension it is getting harder to maintain your home even if you have savings. Yes I think most people are using the equtity in their home to survie
Posted by: Jack | Nov 12, 2021 10:51:30 PM
I am 3 years from retirement. I haven't had a mortgage in 20 years until recently. I just purchased a house on the lake for over 1 million, with no downpayment and a mortgage rate of 1.5%. I used the equity in my other homes to avoid CMHC fees. My mortgage payments per month are huge, but I still end up with more disposable income than I can deal with. I used to just keep investing, looking for tax shelters, etc, but for what purpose? A poor ROI? I am much happier spending on real estate and owning my dream home. Even on my pension, I can afford my mortgage, and still have money to waste. I even support other family members who aren't as financially well off as I am.
So Al, having a mortgage at my age, you say that I should be ashamed of myself? HAHAHAHA! What else should I spend my money on?
Posted by: Contrarian Ontarian | Nov 19, 2021 1:37:38 PM
I entered the world of mortgages at 65 and retired at 69. I carried both a Toronto mid town rental apartment while renovating a fixer upper outside a small village in the Haliburton Highlands. During that time I was doubled up on paying utilities, heat, etc for both residences, plus transportation costs. I have no pension from employment, just RRSP (modest), CPP and OAS plus maxing out my TFSA as an emergency fund.
All this after being a sandwich single with a disabled son and geriatric mother. Both have since passed on and my first financial break in decades. I live a wonderful lifestyle with a small income, space to breathe, a paid for car and some money in the bank.
I say "Freedom 75"! It can be done with careful planning, and not carrying credit card debt.
Lower expectations helps a lot, but the freedom to choose whatever fits is huge!!! I will run out of money by 80 and will then pull the equity out of my home (which won't be paid off).
I am living on less and better than if I had remained in the GTA.